Cognitive Behavioural Therapy have been described as a sticking plaster' for the problems that people may possibly bring to guidance (Observer, 19/02/06). With reference to the literature, critically evaluate the disputes for and against this watch.
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) is a combination of two sorts of therapy; intellectual therapy and behavioural remedy (Bush, 2005). It has been proven to have a good impact on an array of mood and anxiety disorders, such as depression, sleeplessness and panic attacks as well as lately psychosis (schizophrenia).
Yet , whether or not CBT actually resolves the issue currently happening or simply covers it up, being a " staying plaster" (Martin & Helmore, 2006) has recently been a topic of discussion. This has arisen via psychotherapists to whom believe that CBT and it's results are unproven whereas psychiatric therapy has been around for more than a century and worked well for this duration of time, and thus has to be better, in spite of the lack of data available. To quote Holmes (2002), " Absence of Evidence is not Evidence of absence". This issue is of excessive political importance as although psychotherapy has been online for longer, this could not end up being the leading take into account the issue. People's quality of life is what should be considered and if there is a therapy that may highly increase this it should really be taken into mind.
CBT does have it's advantages above other forms of therapy. It is a short term task, usually ranging from 8 to 16 sessions. Plus the hazards of taking on this style of treatment are low, especially when in comparison alongside medicine therapies which may have many unwanted side effects. When compared to psychotheraputical methods, CBT is much less costly and a more short term style of treatment, which will certainly has it's advantages. However , as with any relatively new therapy, really long term effects cannot be completely predicted until it finally has been in work with for many years, however has been merged evidence regarding relapse costs among individuals whom have obtained it (Elkin et 's., 1989). One more issue with CBT is it's clinical relevance. Although efficacy is large, it's specialized medical relevance continues to be questioned, for example, Leff, Vearnals Brewin, Wolff, Alexander and Asen (2000) discluded CBT from their tests in treating despression symptoms due to is actually poor compliance from sufferers whom had been considered as " clinically typical" (Holmes, 2002). Additionally it may show a comparatively slow rate of response (Health 24 Reports, Sleep, 2004) although research is conflicting and a few suggests this kind of not to end up being true.
One of many current main areas of employ for CBT is in the remedying of mood disorders, namely uni-polar depression (depression). Many studies include researched in the efficacy and clinical success of CBT on people suffering from despression symptoms. Butler, Chapman, Forman and Beck (2006) state that credited the large number of psychodynamic practitioners available to treat individuals the most crucial comparisons which in turn need to be made are among these psychodynamic therapies and CBT. One of many largest studies regarding this is carried out by Elkin et al. (1989), comparing the effectiveness of CBT, interpersonal psychotherapy (ITP) and drug remedy. However , no differences had been found involving the treatments of ITP and CBT as well as the effects that were there upon the depressed people, although both equally were discovered to considerably decrease the depressive symptoms of those men. In the more severely despondent patients however , CBT would not fare and either ITP or medicine therapy, indicating that it has limitations inside the treatment of depressive disorder. Sharpio, Barkham, Rees, Sturdy, Reynolds and Startup (1994) used the treatments of CBT and psychodynamic-interpersonal therapy (PIT) in assessing what type was best lawn mowers of the treatment of despression symptoms whilst likewise manipulating the length of treatment. It was found that by the end of the treatment CBT and PIT had been equally as effective. However ,...